Adoption is often discussed from the perspective of the adults involved. We hear about the decision to adopt, the process of becoming a family and the opportunities a child might gain. But what about the adoptee's experience, particularly as they grow older and begin making sense of their own identity?
During my graduate counseling program, I explored research on trauma and adoption, particularly transracial adoption. As a Black transracial adoptee myself, I was especially interested in how researchers understood the relationship between adoption, racial identity and mental health. What I found challenged some familiar narratives surrounding adoption and raised questions about whose perspectives are shaping our understanding of it.
UNDERSTANDING ADOPTION CAN TAKE A LIFETIME
One article that particularly resonated with me was Grace Newton's (2022) The Trauma and Healing of Consciousness. Drawing on her own experiences as an adoptee and social worker, Newton introduces the concept of a "trauma of consciousness," exploring how learning more about adoption and the systems surrounding it can change the way adoptees understand their experiences. Rather than viewing adoption-related trauma as something experienced and understood at one point in time, Newton considers how its meaning can change as adoptees gain new information and perspectives throughout adulthood.
I connected with this because my own understanding of being a Black transracial adoptee has changed considerably over time. Growing up in a white adoptive family, I often heard that my parents "didn't see color." I can understand how that message might have been intended as reassuring, but it didn't change the fact that I was Black or that race would shape how I experienced the world. It wasn't until adulthood that I began to more fully understand how growing up with that message had influenced my relationship with my racial identity.
Newton's work helped me think about how something we didn't question as children may take on an entirely different meaning later in life. But making sense of those experiences can also depend on what information we have access to in the first place.
WHAT HAPPENS WHEN WE DON'T HAVE ACCESS TO OUR OWN HISTORY?
Gina Miranda Samuels (2022) explores this question through the concept of epistemic trauma, examining the harm that can occur when transracial adoptees are denied access to knowledge about their origins or when their understanding of their own experiences is dismissed. I found this particularly meaningful because it asks us to consider what it means to grow up without information that many people take for granted. Questions about biological family history may remain unanswered for years, sometimes indefinitely. Even when that information becomes available later in life, it can change how someone understands their childhood or their cultural identity.
Samuels also examines how adoptees' perspectives can be dismissed when they challenge positive narratives surrounding adoption. There's something troubling about being told how you're supposed to feel about an experience that has shaped so much of your life. Both Samuels and Newton recognize that our understanding of adoption can change throughout adulthood. But adoptees aren't always given access to the information they need to explore their histories, and those barriers can extend beyond individual families.
LOOKING BEYOND INDIVIDUAL FAMILIES
Leonard (2022) examines transracial adoption within a broader history of racial displacement and child removal policies. Commer (2023) questions whether transracial adoption can be considered trauma-informed and argues in favor of non-transracial legal guardianship as an alternative, emphasizing the importance of keeping children connected to their racial and cultural communities.
I appreciated that both authors pushed the conversation beyond the intentions of adoptive parents. Discussions about adoption often focus on whether parents are loving or well-intentioned, but that doesn't fully address the systems influencing which children are separated from their families or the cultural connections they may lose.
Not every transracial adoptee understands their adoption as traumatic. Some may feel deeply connected to their adoptive families while also having complicated relationships with their racial or cultural identities. Others may describe experiences of profound disconnection. A loving adoptive family doesn't automatically protect someone from experiences of racism or cultural disconnection. Those experiences deserve attention, even when someone has a positive relationship with their adoptive family.
WHOSE VOICES ARE WE CENTERING?
Baden and colleagues (2022) propose a substance use disorder prevention program for transracial adoptive families. Their approach recognizes that traditional prevention programs may overlook stressors related to adoption and racial discrimination. I appreciated that the authors acknowledged the need for culturally responsive support.
However, I found myself wondering how much opportunity adoptees had to influence the program's development. What might an intervention like this look like if adoptees played a greater role in shaping it? When researchers study adoption or mental health professionals develop treatment approaches, how much influence do adoptees have over what is being studied and what support is being offered?
As a therapist, I want to remain aware of the assumptions I bring into conversations about adoption. My own experiences inform my perspective, but they don't mean I understand what another adoptee has been through. I also don't want to assume adoption explains every difficulty someone experiences or overlook its potential impact simply because they haven't identified it as a concern.
Reading these articles reinforced how much more there is to learn about transracial adoption, particularly from adoptees whose understanding of their experiences may have changed over time. I came away wanting to see more research shaped by the questions adoptees themselves are asking. Our experiences should influence not only how adoption is studied, but also how the findings are used in mental health care.
If you'd like to learn more about how I think about therapy with adoptees, you can visit my Adoptee Therapy page.
REFERENCES
Baden, A. L., Sharma, S. M., Balducci, S., Ellis, L., Randall, R., Kwon, D., & Harrington, E. S. (2022). A trauma-informed substance use disorder prevention program for transracially adopted children and adolescents. Child Abuse & Neglect, 130, 105598. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chiabu.2022.105598
Commer, C. O. (2023). When 'good intentions' backfire: A case for non-transracial legal guardianship rather than adoption and why transracial adoption is not trauma-informed. Abolitionist Perspectives in Social Work, 1(1). https://doi.org/10.52713/apsw.v1i1.16
Leonard, A. J. (2022). Transracial adoption as continued oppression: Modern practice in context. Columbia Social Work Review, 20(1), 119–140. https://doi.org/10.52214/cswr.v20i1.9645
Newton, G. (2022). The trauma and healing of consciousness. Child Abuse & Neglect, 130, 105563. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chiabu.2022.105563
Samuels, G. E. M. (2022). Epistemic trauma and transracial adoption: Author(iz)ing folkways of knowledge and healing. Child Abuse & Neglect, 130, 105588. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chiabu.2022.105588